1968 a bountiful year for Marvel Comics. The company had just gotten free of a distribution deal that severely limited their output, so they had jammed their creations into titles like Tales of Suspense and Tale to Astonish. Now those creations, the Hulk, the Sub-Mariner, Iron Man, Doctor Strange, among others were getting their own titles. New characters blasted onto the racks, such as Captain Marvel and Captain Savage leading his Leatherneck Raiders. And I was there to enjoy it as a spanking brand-new Marvel fanboy.
And perhaps the biggest debut of the year was Silver Surfer #1, a character deemed so potentially great by Stan Lee that the book was made king-sized. There is certainly no doubt that Marvel had high hopes for this one. The ad is bombastic even by the dizzying heights of bombast that Marvel regularly traded in at the time. But it was not without controversy.
Jack Kirby created the Silver Surfer. No one doubts that. We might quibble about the Fab 4 and other Marvel characters, but the record is pristine relative to the herald of Galactus. And the first issue of The Silver Surfer was produced without any involvement by Kirby. As far as we can tell he was not consulted about it in any way, and he was not pleased. It left a mark and was yet one more reason he'd leave the company he'd helped salvage and transform into a cultural touchstone a few years later.
The assignment was given to "Big" John Buscema, and his work on this title is one of the many reasons he's my all-time favorite comic book artist. (For the record Kirby is second.) And while the Surfer of the early issues of the comic might have cleaved close to Kirby's original model, there's no doubt that by the end of the series Buscema has given us a somewhat different Silver Surfer altogether.
The debut issue gives us an origin. We learn that the Surfer's name is Norrin Radd and that he is originally from the planet Zenn-La. When that planet was threatened by Galactus, Radd sacrificed himself to save his world and Shalla-Bal, the woman he loved. He volunteered to become a herald for Galactus in order to see to it the world eater consumed only world without sentient life. Stan Lee gave the Surfer an origin that was Shakespearean in its appeal. It made the tragic figure of the Silver Surfer even more tragic.
Somehow, I missed the second issue of the Silver Surfer back in the day. Just one of those things, but reading it again today I was struck both by the power of John Buscema's artwork and the devious nature of the attack by the scaly "Brotherhood of the Badoon". Their invisibility was somewhat akin to the Skrulls' shape-changing ways. That the Surfer in fighting the invisible enemy only seems to be destroying property and further creating enemies among the people is quite ironic.
Of course, this issue is part one of one of Marvel's strangest two-parters. The Badoon threaten to return to Earth after their defeat by the Surfer and sure enough they do, a thousand years later in the time of the Guardians of the Galaxy. I did get hold of this one back in the day and loved it. I wish I'd had the companion as a boy. But it's all good now.
That Stan had been presenting the Surfer as being analogous to Christ himself, it's no great surprise that he gets tempted by Satan himself, or more specifically in issue three by Mephisto. This is Mephisto's debut in the Marvel Universe and he selects the Silver Surfer as a being of such high character and nobility that he supplies a sufficient challenge to this master of the hellish depths.
Surviving the temptations of Mephisto, but losing his girl, the sad Surfer is noticed by another god of evil, this one from the Norse canon of myths. Loki is moping and scheming and plots to use the Surfer's power against Thor and to do that he convinces the Surfer that Thor is about to lead an army to attack the walls of Asgard itself. The Surfer seems a tad too gullible but nonetheless it works, and he heads to Asgard to kick some butt. It's a mighty battle.
The fifth issue of The Silver Surfer yielded one of the most emotional stories as the Surfer comes into contact with Al Harper, a physicist who is able perhaps to fashion a way for the Surfer to penetrate the shield that Galactus put around the Earth to keep him prisoner. Harper is a black man and I think Lee wants us to see that he like the Surfer is something of an outsider in society. When the Stranger decides that mankind has been around long enough and builds a bomb to take care of the problem, like some interstellar exterminator, only the Surfer and Harper stand in his way.
Sal's inking changes somewhat in the sixth issue, the Surfer being less a glistening object and more merely a pure white presence. Reading these stories in Essential volume works well as black and white serves the art of Big John and his little brother quite well. The Surfer goes to the future and finds the Overlord, a malicious mutant who has destroyed most of sentient life in the universe and enslaved the remainder. He's more powerful than the Surfer, but our hero still finds a way to win the day.
It's a different kind of story in the seventh issue as the Surfer encounters a Frankenstein, a mad scientist who wants to surpass the misdeeds of his ancestor. To that end he fashions a deadly doppleganger of the Surfer and it's all the Surfer can do to beat himself. This seemed a strange story after the broad sci-fi of the previous two issues. Sadly, this is also the last issue inked by Sal Buscema who of course went on to become a mainstay artist at Marvel for a few decades.
Mephisto is firmly established as the Silver Surfer's nemesis when he returns and brings with him a souped-up ghost especially designed to bring the Surfer to his knees and pledge allegiance to Mephisto. The Ghost is actually the legendary Flying Dutchman. The comic has shifted from a bi-monthly king-size to a monthly regular edition. To do that the original Ghost story was split into two parts. Dan Adkins steps in, to ink Buscema and does a wonderful job, and brings back a little of the Surfer's sheen.
In another two-part story Shalla Bal convinces the unscrupulous scientist Yarro Gort to bring her to Earth to find the Surfer. How she knows he's on Earth is never addressed to my knowledge. The Surfer is embroiled with an invasion of a nameless South American country when the ship arrives and is shot down. He doesn't know Shalla Bal is on Earth until she is shot, and he is forced to send her back to Zenn-La to receive treatment.
It was about this time that Martin Goodman mandated that all Marvel Comics be one-issue stories and so the Silver Surfer book conforms for the brief time this mandate is in force. The first of these one-off adventures by Lee, Buscema and Adkins had the Surfer fall literally into the clutches of a coven of witches which conjures up the Abomination, the gamma-ray powered monster last seen in the pages of Tales to Astonish. It's pure strength against the power cosmic. One can detect a number of John Romita touch-ups in this issue.
The Doomsday Man is a robot. An indestructible robot which is imprisoned by his creators on a distant island, but which gets loose. Only the Surfer has a chance to stop the Earth-shaking threat when the robot gets his metallic mitts on a cobalt bomb. Stan's plotting in this one is pretty shaky but I've always liked this parable pleading for peace on Earth.
I'd guess that sales reports were not promising for the series, so in issue fourteen Stan played the web-slinging card and had Spider-Man guest star in the title. It's a typical Marvel heroes ruckus with both sides full of regret. Spidey often was called upon to battle Marvel stars more powerful than he was, because he had a power many of them lacked to the same degree and that was the ability to sell comics to the merry marching minions of Marveldom.
After Spidey we get another helping of guest-star assistance when the Human Torch tries to stop the Surfer. The Silver Surfer had been growing ever more cynical as the series progressed, going from seeking to assist man to just hoping to find a refuge away from people, to now firing the first shot when he thinks he's under threat. Whether Stan meant it or not, it's easy to see the Surfer getting more and more miffed as the months roll by. He makes his share of mistakes, but things are only going to get worse. This is the last issue inked by Dan Adkins by the way.
Chic Stone returns to the Marvel fold to ink Buscema's pencils on the sixteenth and seventeenth issues of the run. Mephisto returns again to try and gain the Surfer's soul. His gambit this time is to kidnap Shalla Bal and bring her to Earth and hide her within the spy outfit SHIELD. At the same time, he goads the Surfer to attack SHIELD hoping that the Surfer will fall into despair when he finds out he killed his own beloved. Nick Fury and his agents fight to fend off the Surfer who refuses to take lives. Mephisto is frustrated and sends Shalla Bal home to Zenn-La.
In the eighteenth and final Silver Surfer issue the wounded Surfer returns to Earth smack dab in the middle of Inhumans territory. The Inhumans are having a bit of a civil war with Maximus the Mad once again leading his rebels against Black Bolt and the Royal Family. The Surfer cannot really tell friend from foe and fights with everyone. His frustration builds until he bursts out in anger.
In this iconic final page of a final comic in a series the Surfer declares that he's had all he can stand and he can't stands no more. (To quote a famous sailor...sort of.) As you can see this page was drawn by Jack Kirby, the Surfer's creator. He drew the final issue on his way out the door of Marvel as he headed over to DC to kick off the Fourth World. This issue features a cover by Herb Trimpe who also does a great job inking Kirby's pencils.
And that's a wrap.
The next time we see the Silver Surfer in the Marvel Universe it is as part of the "Titanic Three" alongside the Hulk and the Sub-Mariner in the pages of the latter's comic. This Silver Surfer event gives Sal Buscema his first chance to pencil the Surfer as well as ink him.
The Silver Surfer was a remarkable comic in its time. Stan Lee didn't create the Silver Surfer, but in this series, he defined the character with John Buscema who transformed his look. Stan loved writing the Silver Surfer, a character who could slide along in the skies and pop off one soliloquy after another. Stan's operatic writing style was ideal for the meandering mopey often self-loathing speeches the Surfer launched panel after panel. Thanks to John Buscema the Surfer went from a typical muscle-bound hero to a lithe and lanky figure, distinctive and even weak looking at times. The Surfer was often shown on his knees, pleading for understanding and to understand the world on which he found himself. We follow along as he slowly but relentlessly loses his grip and finally is utterly overcome with anger and resentment. I'm not sure that was the plan, but it sure was the journey.
Stan tucked the Silver Surfer away after this series folded, only letting others use him sparingly over the next many years. He'd show up once in a while as a guest star, appear in some of Marvel's graphic novels including the only new material Fireside book, and ultimately get a new series finally at long last in 1987. I've enjoyed this fresh reading of these stories. They hold up.
That concludes our Easter special Silver Surfer coverage here at the Dojo. Check in tomorrow for something completely different. Enjoy the holiday!
Rip Off
Sorry but the Silver Surfer was just boring. His constant whining about worthless Mankind got tiresome pretty quickly and it was utterly hypocritical coming from someone who'd helped Galactus destroy countless civilisations. The Surfer's origin was awful and I'd have happily shot that dreadful woman Shalla-Bal so I'm not surprised Jack Kirby was angry.
ReplyDeleteHappy Easter, Rip!
I can see that. But following him from the beginning, he began strong and I'd agree became pedantic by the end. I don't think I mentioned it in my post, but on this read I noticed how often he'd give up on mankind, just to look for good yet again.
DeleteThis has been a memorable tribute to the era of Marvel greatness. At first I thought The Silver Surfer was one odd character. I mean an alien riding a cosmic surfboard? My teenage mind couldn't quite get wrapped around that. I soon got used to the idea and went along willingly for the ride. Nice posts!
ReplyDeleteKirby could do that. Take an absurd concept and make it seem plausible. It almost worked even for the Black Racer...almost. Thanks for the kind words.
DeleteCan't agree with CJ that the Surfer mags were boring; issues 10-14 were particularly entertaining. (Mephisto was perhaps overused in other issues though.) Have I mentioned I've got all 18 original numbers? And also the Omnibus volume. (Boasting again.)
ReplyDeleteI've been waiting for years for the Epic collection, and finally gave up and used my Essential volume for this review. I have all of the originals as well, but I read originals so rarely these days, hardly at all.
DeleteThe Surfer was one of my favourite characters as a kid even although I only ever managed to pick up one issue (#12) of his original series ( before reading these in the UK reprint "Super-Heroes" comic) . Similar to John, I just loved the concept of the character including his "whining", which admittedly was overplayed by Stan . It would have been nice though to have seen Kirby do a few issues of the Surfer just to see where he would take the character in a solo comic. Regardless, I still think the Silver Surfer is one of comics greatest characters. Great posts Rip .
ReplyDeleteThe Surfer was an example of overacting, but issue by issue it works. Over the course of several issues it gets a bit tiresome, but that's not the way really that comics should be read or not back then. The Surfer was created completely by Kirby but in this case improved by Lee. Rare instance indeed.
DeleteI'm bound to say, RJ, that Lee often (if not always) improved Kirby's side of things. I very much doubt that most of the Marvel heroes would've caught on in the way they did had Jack scripted them himself.
DeleteTo CJ's comment about the Surfer being guilty of mass destruction of living planets-- which is certainly alluded to in the Galactus Trilogy-- Stan alters that aspect of the character in SILVER SURFER #1. Under Lee and Buscema, the Surfer is no longer an imponderable cosmic being that can't relate to ordinary mortals. He's a transformed mortal with a full range of human feelings. Stan rewrites the Surfer's history to say that since his genesis the hero steered his master away from inhabited planets. So Galactus' attack on Earth was functionally the first time the Surfer was unable to divert his "creator" to some neutral planetary body.
ReplyDeleteI always imagined in the trilogy that the Surfer had served Galactus for a long time, but when he's turned into Norrin Radd and Shalla Bal is still alive, it all makes it seem like much less time has elapsed.
Delete