It was striking that it's now 2021 and been a full decade since I last read some of my most favorite stories in all the comic book world. I know, because at the time I carefully recorded my impressions and thoughts on this very blog. Now I'd like to read those fanciful DC yarns again and since rewriting these reviews would be nonsensical, I rather represent them here with some fresh decoration and perhaps a fresh insight or two thrown in for goodly measure. Le me begin at the beginning.
From 1961,"The Flash of Two Worlds" in The Flash #123 was deftly written by Gardner Fox and delicately drawn by Carmine Infantino and Joe Giella. Under an iconic Infantino and Murphy Anderson cover, we meet Barry Allen who while doing a benefit for Iris West and some unfortunate kids accidently vibrates himself out of his world onto what will be dubbed "Earth-2". He soon enough realizes that Keystone City, in which he finds himself, is the home of his boyhood comic book hero Jay Garrick, the Flash of the Golden Age.
He looks up Garrick in the phone book and soon enough he finds himself sitting in the Garrick home explaining things to Jay and his wife Joan. We discover that Gardner Fox must have been tuned into Earth-2 to create the adventures of the Golden Age Flash, who being several years older than Barry Allen has gone into retirement along with all of the Justice Society of America.
But as happens so often in these tales, a threat, specifically the alliance of three classic Flash villains, the Fiddler, the Thinker, and the Shade cause Barry and Jay to team up and predictably defeat the baddies who are shocked to find two Flashes in the way of their schemes to rob and plunder.
What is most striking about this story is its gentility. Barry finds himself on another world and very logically and simply finds his counterpart. They meet without rancor or suspicion and with a politeness only seen at the time in a DC comic they meticulously defeat the baddies. It's a whimsical and downright charming encounter.
Never quite liked the Earth 1/Earth 2 set up, to be honest, but I bought the replica edition of The Flash #123, even though I have a number of reprints of the tale already. It's a fascinating cover.
ReplyDeleteIt's one of those iconic ones that gets swiped constantly. As for the multiple Earths notion, I adore it and the possibilities it opened up for storytelling. The DCU post-Crisis on Infinite Earths felt small and restrictive to me and it wasn't long before they opened it up again.
DeleteI think it was the fact that Earth 2 should really have been Earth 1 (and vice-versa) that didn't sit right with me. After all, the heroes all appeared on Earth 2 first. And although some of the stories were entertaining from a kid's point of view, it all seemed absurdly convoluted once comics started to be aimed at older readers in the '70s and '80s. DC's messed things up completely now, what with all their various reboots since the original Crisis. I don't know whether I'm coming or going when it comes to continuity and have simply given up buying new DC mags, except for an occasional Anniversary issue.
Delete