I've heard about The Starlost for most of my life, but I'd never seen an episode of this notorious science fiction series. My knowledge was most likely a result of reading and reading about Harlan Ellison, the sci-fi writer who concocted the story this series is based on and who wrote the script for the debut episdoe. The Starlost is considered by some to be the worst science fiction series ever and I can vouch that it's not that.
But the guy who first thought it all up was not happy and was so unhappy in fact that he had his named removed and this standby identity of "Cordwainer Bird" punched in to fill the void. Ellison tells the tale of how he was much abused (Ellison is always much abused in his stories) by the folks who wanted to produce this show and how they made promises they either couldn't or had no intention of keeping. I'll take a look at the novel he made with Ed Bryant some time later which presumably puts forth his rendition of this story. But first here's the show.
We meet Devon, an iconoclastic member of an Amish sect which finds its world oddly circumspect. With a limited territory and a limited sky and a limited population the village uses authoritarian techniques to keep the balance. Devon does not fit in, he wants to marry Rachel the girl he loves despite the fact she is promised to another, his friend in fact, a blacksmith named Garth. Devon's confrontations withe powers result in his isolation but he never relents and eventually discovers that all is not what it seems. This Amish clan is floating in space and they don't even know it.
The first episode shows how Devon begins to find the truth and how when he tries to share that truth with his people he is yet again condemned. The three friends end up outside the society and together begin to learn the real truth of their existence. Some of that truth is that they live on a great Ark, a spaceship which was borrowed from the Bruce Dern film Silent Running.
I didn't find The Starlost to be all that bad, a tendency to be dull but certainly possessing special effects typical of the era. Most of the dullness is in the oddball flat way the acting is done. All the actors seem to do it, to demonstrate general lethargy punctuated by moments of furious activity, so I think it must have been intended. Perhaps they confused ponderous silence with presumed wisdom, but whatever the case it hurts the viewing. As the series tumbles along it does tweak with its look and premise a bit, and toward the end seems to treat our trio of stalwarts as folks more comfortable with technology. That's natural of course, but it felt more like a reboot than an evolution. I've seen worse.
More on The Starlost tomorrow.
Rip Off
Rip Off
Rip, I hate to complain but you never provide any DATES for the things you review so I had to visit Wikipedia to discover that The Starlost was originally broadcast from September 1973 to January 1974 and you also didn't mention that the series was Canadian (I'd never heard of The Starlost until today).
ReplyDeleteSorry about that. I never want to write down to my audience (though I've been accused of that). I assume you know something already, if not much more. But it is surprising even to me that that there's no date in there at all.
DeleteI wonder if Ellison ever considered wearing a crash helmet when he butted heads with so many publishers, producers, etc. It seemed like he was chronically unsatisfied with whatever work he did for others. I guess it goes along with a very imaginative, highly-critical mind.
ReplyDeleteHe seemed always to want a bit more, which ain't wrong. He was working in fields that typically took advantage, so I bet he just kept up his defenses. Some of his lawsuits he pressed were the very definition of frivolous.
DeleteI probably saw all the episodes rerun on commercial TV at some point, but I remember almost nothing about the stories. I think the basic concept was a lot like FANTASTIC JOURNEY, in that the protagonists visited a new culture every week, often if not always solving that culture's problems before getting back to the quest for their own world. FJ, though, had the advantage that the heroes could always find new dimensional worlds, while those of STARLOST were limited to whatever was already present in their "wagon train in space." But yes, certainly not the worst of its genre.
ReplyDeleteInteresting comparison. Fantastic Journey is a show I know less about.
Delete